Dining and Drinking Review - The Sherlock Holmes

Location: Melbourne CBD, Victoria
Date of visit: 27 June 2026
Overall score: 5/5

Elementary, my dear Thirsty Tourists! 🕵️

While exploring the Melbourne CBD, we stumbled across a little piece of British pub culture tucked away beneath the streets – The Sherlock Holmes Inn.

Down the stairs we went into this cosy basement pub, and it certainly had that traditional British pub atmosphere. Warm, welcoming and full of character, it was just the sort of place that makes you want to pull up a stool and settle in for a while.

The beer selection was impressive, with 19 beers on tap, so there was certainly plenty to investigate. Choosing just one could prove to be a serious case for deduction! 😂

The menu featured all the traditional pub grub you’d expect, making it an easy decision to stop for lunch.

And what better excuse to enjoy another Hobgoblin Ruby Ale?

I’d already developed a bit of a soft spot for this particular drop, so discovering another opportunity to enjoy one was a definite win. Some mysteries are better left unsolved, but finding another good ale certainly isn’t one of them!

Lunch, a great pub atmosphere and a decent ale. What more could a Thirsty Tourist ask for?

The Thirsty Tourists verdict

A cosy little British-style pub worth investigating if you’re exploring Melbourne’s CBD. We’d happily return for another meal and, naturally, further research into that beer selection.

No mystery there!

🍻 The Thirsty Tourists – Touring is thirsty work!

#TheThirstyTourists #TouringIsThirstyWork #SherlockHolmesInn #MelbournePubs #MelbourneCBD #PubReview #HobgoblinRubyAle #PubGrub

Overall
Rated 5 out of 5
Location
Rated 5 out of 5
Menu
Rated 5 out of 5
Value
Rated 5 out of 5

You might also enjoy: